Skip to main content

iDeal Auto Sales of Of Bensonhurst, NY

Sell Your Car | Loading schedule...
Used cars on the showroom floor at iDeal Automotive Sales of Bensonhurst in Brooklyn, NY

New York Used Car Lemon Law: What It Covers and How to Use It

iDeal Automotive
Used cars on the showroom floor at iDeal Automotive Sales of Bensonhurst in Brooklyn, NY

The NY used car lemon law requires a New York dealer to give you a written warranty when you buy a used car. During that warranty, the dealer must repair covered defects, and if it can’t fix a serious one after a reasonable chance, you’re entitled to your money back. The law is New York General Business Law §198-b. This guide explains which cars qualify, how long the warranty lasts, which parts it covers, and what to do if your car keeps breaking down. It is written by iDeal Automotive Sales of Bensonhurst, a used car dealership in Brooklyn, and reflects the law as of October 2026.

What the NY Used Car Lemon Law Does

A dealer must give you a written warranty on every covered used car. While the warranty lasts, the dealer has to repair any covered part that fails, or pay you the reasonable cost of having it repaired. If a defect substantially impairs the car’s value and the dealer can’t fix it after a reasonable number of tries, the dealer must refund the full purchase price.

The dealer must also hand you a notice titled “Used Car Lemon Law Bill of Rights,” which summarizes these protections in plain language. The written warranty has to be delivered at or before the time you sign the sales or lease contract.

Which Sellers and Cars Are Covered?

Dealers, not private sellers

The law applies to dealers. In New York, a dealer is anyone who sells, leases or offers used vehicles after selling, offering or leasing three or more of them in the previous 12 months. A private sale between two people is not covered.

The car itself

A used car is covered when all of these are true:

  • You paid $1,500 or more for it.
  • It had 100,000 miles or less when you bought it.
  • It is used mainly for personal, family or household purposes. A business-owned car can still qualify if it is used personally more than half the time.
  • It is not a motor home, an off-road vehicle or a historical vehicle. Used motorcycles have been covered since September 1, 2004.

Very low-mileage cars are a special case. The Bill of Rights says: “If your used car has 18,000 miles or less, you may be protected by the new car lemon law.” That separate law, General Business Law §198-a, deals with defects the manufacturer must fix.

How Long the Used Car Warranty Lasts

The minimum warranty depends on the car’s mileage when you buy it. It ends at whichever limit comes first, the days or the miles.

Mileage when you buyMinimum warranty
36,000 miles or less90 days or 4,000 miles
More than 36,000 but less than 80,00060 days or 3,000 miles
80,000 to 100,00030 days or 1,000 miles
More than 100,000 (stated in writing at the sale)Not covered by this law

These are minimums, so a dealer can offer more. In addition, a covered problem you report during the warranty must still be repaired even if the warranty runs out before the repair is finished.

Which Parts the Warranty Covers

The warranty must cover at least these parts:

  • Engine, including all lubricated parts, the water pump, fuel pump, manifolds, engine block, cylinder head, rotary engine housings and flywheel
  • Transmission
  • Drive axle
  • Brakes
  • Radiator
  • Steering
  • Alternator, generator, starter and ignition system, excluding the battery

Many other parts aren’t covered. The New York Attorney General lists the battery, body and tires as examples.

When You Can Get a Refund

The dealer gets a reasonable chance to fix the problem first. The law presumes the dealer has had that chance if, during the warranty period, either of these happened:

  • the same defect was repaired three or more times, or
  • the car was out of service for repairs for a total of 15 or more days.

Days spent waiting for parts don’t count toward the 15 days as long as the dealer is diligent. However, once the car has been out of service for 45 days in total, you are entitled to a remedy regardless.

If the defect still substantially impairs the car’s value, the dealer must refund the full purchase price, including sales tax. The dealer may subtract an allowance only for damage beyond normal wear and for modifications, and the Attorney General notes that “there is no deduction for mileage.” The dealer can offer a replacement car instead, but you don’t have to accept it.

On the other hand, a dealer can refuse a refund if the defect doesn’t substantially impair the car’s value, or if it was caused by abuse, neglect, or unreasonable modifications or alterations.

Can a Dealer Sell a Used Car “As Is” in New York?

Not a car the law covers. Any waiver of the lemon law warranty is void, and if a dealer fails to give you the written warranty, the law treats the dealer as having given it anyway. As the Attorney General puts it, “No dealer can sell you a car ‘as is.'”

Separately, New York Vehicle and Traffic Law §417 requires a dealer to state in writing that the car “is in condition and repair to render, under normal use, satisfactory and adequate service upon the public highway at the time of delivery.”

What the Written Warranty Can Exclude

The law allows the written warranty to exclude certain problems. These exclusions only apply if they are written into your warranty, so read it before you sign. The permitted exclusions include:

  • problems caused by a lack of customary maintenance;
  • damage from a collision, abuse, negligence, theft, vandalism, fire or other casualty, or the environment;
  • an altered odometer or an altered part;
  • normal maintenance items and tune-ups;
  • racing, towing (unless the car is equipped for it), carrying passengers for hire, and use as a rental.

If you plan to use the car for rideshare or other paid driving, ask the dealer how the warranty treats that use before you buy.

How to Use Your Rights

  1. Tell the dealer in writing. Report the problem during the warranty period and keep a copy.
  2. Keep every repair order. They show how many times, and for how many days, the car was in for repairs.
  3. Use arbitration if the dealer won’t fix the car or refund you. The New York Attorney General runs a Lemon Law Arbitration Program, administered by the New York State Dispute Resolution Association (NYSDRA). NYSDRA lists a $120 filing fee for used car cases, refunded if you win, and the decision is binding on both sides.
  4. Or go to court. You can sue the dealer directly instead of using arbitration.

A claim must be brought within four years of the date the car was originally delivered to you. Also, if the dealer takes part in a federal informal dispute program (16 CFR Part 703), you may need to use that program before asking for a refund.

Proposed Changes to Watch in 2026

New York lawmakers have proposed expanding the used car lemon law. Bills A8594-A and S8430 would, among other changes, raise the minimum warranty to 12 months or 12,000 miles for cars with up to 80,000 miles. As of October 2026, neither bill has passed, so the warranty periods above still apply. We’ll update this guide if the law changes.

Buying a Used Car in Brooklyn With Confidence

New York law requires every dealer, including us, to give you the lemon law warranty in writing before you sign. At iDeal Automotive Sales of Bensonhurst, ask your salesperson to walk you through the warranty and the Bill of Rights for any car you’re considering.

Before you visit, check our list of the documents you need to buy a car in New York, and read our step-by-step car buying guide. Then browse our used cars for sale in Brooklyn, or visit us at 8635 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214. You can also call (718) 888-8188.

NY Used Car Lemon Law FAQ

Is there a lemon law for used cars in NY?

Yes. General Business Law §198-b requires dealers to give a written warranty on used cars sold for $1,500 or more with up to 100,000 miles, and to repair or refund cars with covered defects.

Does the NY lemon law apply to private sales?

No. The used car lemon law only covers cars bought from dealers. If you buy from a private seller, it doesn’t apply.

How long is the used car warranty in New York?

It depends on the mileage at purchase: 90 days or 4,000 miles for 36,000 miles or less; 60 days or 3,000 miles for more than 36,000 but less than 80,000; and 30 days or 1,000 miles for 80,000 to 100,000.

How many repair attempts make a used car a lemon in NY?

The dealer is presumed to have had a reasonable chance to fix the car after three or more repairs of the same defect, or 15 or more total days out of service, during the warranty period. If the defect still substantially impairs the car’s value, you’re entitled to a refund.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. For help with a specific car, contact the New York Attorney General’s office or a lawyer. Source: New York State Attorney General, Used Car Lemon Law.

Related Articles

Front three-quarter view of a white 2015 Honda CR-V Touring SUV with alloy wheels at a Brooklyn car dealership.

Why the 2015 Honda CR-V Touring Still Makes Sense Today

Discover the 2015 Honda CR-V Touring, featuring smooth performance, leather seating, advanced driver-assistance technology, and flexible cargo space. Explore used SUV options at iDeal Auto Sales of Bensonhurst in Brooklyn, New York.

Find Your Next Ride with iDeal Auto Sales of Bensonhurst

Contact our team for vehicle availability, financing guidance, and your best next step.